The Shadow Story

Julie McGue
Author
In honor of National Adoption Awareness Month, I wanted to post a recap of my own adoption story and how I have come to view the journey I undertook nearly fifteen years ago.
When I first spoke to my birth mother on the phone, I closed my eyes and opened them again just to prove what was happening wasn’t a dream. For more than fifty years, closed adoption laws had barred my twin sister and me from knowing anything about our first family. Yet I had always wondered what they looked like, why they placed us for adoption, and whom we resembled. Then after years of searching, the phone rang, and there she was. As she spoke, I glimpsed the life I almost lived—my shadow story.
My identical twin sister and I were adopted together as infants, a mercy for which I have always been grateful. We had a loving childhood filled with Sunday suppers, drive-in movie nights, beach vacations, and holidays spent with aunts, uncles, and cousins. Our parents told us at an early age about our adoption, and every so often they did a check-in. They expressed how deeply they wanted us. But when they promised to help if we ever sought more information about our background, I caught the way they looked at one another. The uneasiness I felt in their words and manner taught me that our adoption story was better left alone. Because I loved my family and felt a strong sense of belonging, I decided to leave it alone, too.
That all changed in my late forties when a routine mammogram led to a breast biopsy. The results were benign, but the experience forced me to confront what closed adoption had kept from us. Leaving well enough alone no longer felt wise. It felt risky. My sister and I decided to search for our birth relatives. We told our adoptive parents we were only seeking names, dates, medical history, and ancestry. But in truth, I was also pursuing answers to questions I had suppressed for decades: Who am I, and where do I belong?
The search consumed five years and brought multiple setbacks and false leads, demanding more emotional stamina than I ever imagined. When we reached out to our birth mother, she refused contact with us. The rejection devastated me. After the tears dried and my anger faded, I realized how deeply I craved her acknowledgement—not as a problem from the past, but as a daughter from the present.
Eventually, she changed her mind and reached out. Our reunion was a gentle unfolding. First, we exchanged letters and photographs, then phone calls, and finally, we met in person. During that face-to-face meeting, she handed my sister and me a packet of family photos and genealogy. My hands shook as I slid the items out of the envelope and saw for the first time that I looked like someone else besides my twin. I learned that I had French, German, and Native American ancestry and received pieces of the medical history I had needed for years. In one weekend, I acquired what most people learn gradually: whose likeness they carry, what illnesses run through their family, and what stories shaped the generations before them.
I also learned why we had been placed for adoption. When my birth mother told my father about her pregnancy, he said he didn’t love her and wouldn’t marry her. All this was in opposition to the adolescent fantasy I’d harbored for years of a different, better family out there waiting to be found.
My birth mother had carried the stigma and shame of her unwed pregnancy around with her for decades. She sometimes tried to shift this onto my sister and me by refusing to introduce us to folks who might judge her. But our adoptive parents had raised us to feel loved, capable, confident, unstained by our birth circumstances. When I contacted my birth father, he denied us but forwarded medical information that proved how vital our search had become: breast cancer ran in his bloodline. He died suddenly without ever meeting us.
The more I learned about my birth relatives, the more I understood that the life I almost lived was not paradise lost. I had naively imagined that shared biology might create instant understanding or restore bonds that had been severed long ago. Instead, I discovered that family, even when found, remains as fragile and complicated as any other relationship. Reunion did not erase the pain of adoption. Instead, in some ways it uncovered fresh layers of it.
One moment crystallized this for me. During the “honeymoon phase” of reunion, I would call my birth mother just to chat. One day, after some small talk, she paused, asking, “What do you want?” The question stunned me. “Isn’t it obvious?” I stammered. “I want a mother-daughter relationship.” I wanted to know and understand her, to belong to her, and have her belong to me. I couldn’t understand why she didn’t intuit that. Her question forced me to recognize that the life I almost lived could not be recovered, only glimpsed. Whatever connection was possible between us would have to be built from the present onward.
My unlived life shimmered before me like a lost inheritance: I could see enough of it to mourn, but not enough to possess it. Reunion offered no repaired beginning or simple folding back into the family from which I had come. It offered a late-in-life gathering of names, faces, stories, illnesses, and partial affections. It did not cancel adoption loss. It asked me to hold grief and gratitude together.
If my birth parents had married and kept us, I might have been spared the lifelong wondering. I might have known my two birth siblings from the beginning and carried my ancestry without question. But knowing what I know now, I cannot say that my family of origin would have offered the steadier path.
Still, I am grateful for the glimpse. My search gave me family history, medical background, siblings, and context. It helped me understand the shame, fear, secrecy, and judgement that once surrounded adoption. Most of all, it gave me a fuller understanding of myself. For much of my life, adoption was a closed door I chose not to rattle. Once it opened, I discovered not only who had been standing behind it, but also how much of myself had been waiting there, too.
I will always wonder what might have happened had my birth parents married and raised my sister and me. But I no longer romanticize that unlived life as the better life. I see it as the other life, a shadow story running alongside the one I have lived. Glimpsing that shadow story taught me that identity is not a single inheritance and that belonging is rarely simple. My life has been shaped both by what was given and by what was withheld, by the family that raised me and the one that I found. In seeing more clearly the life I might have led, I have come to understand the one I did live and to claim it as my own.
Follow Me Here
November 2-30, I’m participating in Deb Landwehr Engle’s month-long course at Story Summit called The Writer’s Miracle Method which is based on Deb’s hot new release by the same title.
November 19, thrilled to be a panelist for the She Writes Press C.A.M.P community when we gather with an expert from Net Galley to discuss the importance of book reviews.
November 20, James Lott will host me on his podcast, In Between the Pages, and we will discuss all things writing. Link forthcoming.
November 24, My interview with JoAnn Dickinson, host of Beyond the Book will air on November 24. Link to preview clip: https://drive.google.com/file/d/1JN6CjftaQw0T40LL2vEmVfh-O89xe655/view
March 8 – 12, 2027: I will attend the Her Spirit women’s writing retreat put on by Story Summit in Tucson, Arizona at El Conquistador Tucson, A Hilton Resort.
Follow Julie by visiting her website, subscribe to her bimonthly newsletters, and listen to previous podcast recordings where she discusses topics like adoption, identity, family relationships, sisterhood and belonging.
PUBLISHING NEWS
Summer of 2027: Book 2 in my Let’s Go with Lulu children’s book series, Lulu and DJ Go to the Car Wash, will release next summer with Atmosphere Press. It’s based on the real-life story about adventures with my oldest grandson during the COVID era. Book 1: Jack and Lulu Go to the Tree Farm will also be moving over to Atmosphere Press very soon. I’m excited that the entire series will be under one publishing umbrella.
November 7, 2027: My re-envisioned essay collection, Belonging Matters: Conversations on Adoption, Family, and Kinship, will be re-published by She Writes Press. I’m thrilled to move this work under the same publishing umbrella that offers my award-winning memoirs: Twice a Daughter, and Twice the Family.
“I will always wonder what might have happened had my birth parents married and raised my sister and me. But I no longer romanticize that unlived life as the better life. I see it as the other life, a shadow story running alongside the one I have lived.“
Don’t miss a blog post!
Receive my blog posts directly to your inbox.